Your Tax Dollars At Work

Non-music discussion. Discuss things that are on your mind or things that don't have anything to do with music. Lets try to keep it clean people, there are little children present.

Moderators: MrSpall, bassjones, sevesd93, zenmandan

G Fresh
RockStar
RockStar
Posts: 740
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 12:18 pm
Location: Nashville, TN
Contact:

Your Tax Dollars At Work

Post by G Fresh »

http://www.myspace.com/matthewgates
http://www.youtube.com/MattyGFresh
Support Local Original Music
Sankofa
Too Much Free Time
Too Much Free Time
Posts: 1512
Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2004 1:17 pm
Location: home
Contact:

Re: Your Tax Dollars At Work

Post by Sankofa »

The object of the program is to determine if paying students to study will improve classroom attendance, grades and test scores, according to a news release from the district.
Reading the above, I'd say yes, it's a good idea.
The initiative is funded by Charles Loudermilk, chairman and chief executive officer of Aaron Rents, through the Learning Makes A Difference Foundation. The foundation is a local non-profit designed to improve education through creative programs.
Perhaps if you'd read the entire article, you'd see that it wasn't tax dollars at work, but rather private funds. Now, unless I unwittingly changed my name to Charles Loudermilk, my tax dollars have about as much to do with this study as your post.
deek
Staff Writer
Staff Writer
Posts: 1060
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 4:31 pm
Location: Fort Wayne, IN
Contact:

Post by deek »

Paying students to study and attend class...isn't that called scholarship and grant money?

I think you'd find a lot better students in class if you didn't make it required. Let the kids that don't want to school quit. Let the ones that don't want to go to college never enroll. The ones that really want to study and attend class will eventually do it and the won't need to get paid to motivate them.
[url=http://www.deeksworld.com]deek's World[/url]
bwohlgemuth
Addict
Addict
Posts: 851
Joined: Sat Jun 26, 2004 10:44 pm
Location: Huntington, IN
Contact:

Post by bwohlgemuth »

This is quite ironic.

My wife substitute teaches part time. Today she was helping a class full of 7th & 8th graders.

She was required to do the kids homework for them. Not help. Not tutor. Do it. One kid called her a b*tch when she told him to start reading since:

a) He could read
b) He didn't want to

The teacher in charge did nothing. My wife brought the kid to the office and the principal made the kids apologize.

And now we want to pay these kids....give me a break.
G Fresh
RockStar
RockStar
Posts: 740
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 12:18 pm
Location: Nashville, TN
Contact:

Re: Your Tax Dollars At Work

Post by G Fresh »

Sankofa wrote:
The object of the program is to determine if paying students to study will improve classroom attendance, grades and test scores, according to a news release from the district.
Reading the above, I'd say yes, it's a good idea.
The initiative is funded by Charles Loudermilk, chairman and chief executive officer of Aaron Rents, through the Learning Makes A Difference Foundation. The foundation is a local non-profit designed to improve education through creative programs.
Perhaps if you'd read the entire article, you'd see that it wasn't tax dollars at work, but rather private funds. Now, unless I unwittingly changed my name to Charles Loudermilk, my tax dollars have about as much to do with this study as your post.
Well pardon me for accidentally mislabeling it. All I meant was, this is described as a "pilot program" which usually means if it's "successful" it will probably be forced through legislation to become a taxpayer funded part of the public school system.

Here's one of my questions about it, what do the kids who are already doing well in school get? Shouldn't they get paid as well as a reward for succeeding academically?

When did it become politically incorrect to want someone to strive after good grades for the sake of the grade and getting a good education rather than to get paid? Granted, in the long run usually one of the goals of a good education is to get a better paying job, but when you're in public high school and already getting a "free" education, I don't see why you should get paid spending cash on top of that, especially as a bribe to study and do your homework.

That being said, if Mr. Loudermilk wants to keep spending his money on things like this, God bless him. I just hope that it doesn't go beyond that.
http://www.myspace.com/matthewgates
http://www.youtube.com/MattyGFresh
Support Local Original Music
WBOB
Too Much Free Time
Too Much Free Time
Posts: 1420
Joined: Fri Jan 27, 2006 4:51 pm
Location: ....in the express lane

Post by WBOB »

one word.... no!
.


Less is always more
bassjones
Staff Member
Staff Member
Posts: 4270
Joined: Mon May 24, 2004 1:36 pm
Contact:

Post by bassjones »

I'm guessing it will have no impact anyway and then the pilot program will go away. If there's any impact at all, it will be short term.
"brad!
...your tunes and your playing sound really great... all the best to you and god bless-
adam nitti" www.myspace.com/adamnittimusic

www.bradjonesbass.com
http://groups.myspace.com/northeastindianabassplayers
www.myspace.com/bassjones
www.myspace.com/whitehotnoise
www.esession.com/bradjones - hire me for your session from anywhere in the world.
=^-..-^=
FEED ME!
FEED ME!
Posts: 971
Joined: Sat Feb 22, 2003 11:22 am
Location: Rockin' the CatBox

Post by =^-..-^= »

I ask, why are all you free-market capitalists so dead set against INCENTIVES? Isn't the profit motive what makes our economic system prosper? Shouldn't we be training kids how to prosper in that system by giving them an immediate tangible EXAMPLE? Intrinsic rewards? Eventual payoff in a better job? Most kids aren't thinking much beyond this weekend most of the time, and many students haven't witnessed the benefits of a diploma in the people around them. I wish I could afford to buy a pizza for every kid that gets an A.

The warm fuzzy feeling inside for doing a good job just doesn't cut it any more with kids in this consumer-goods laden Nintendo society. Show them the money. Put a pizza coupon in the kid's hand for passing ISTEP, and I bet many would stop drawing little smiley faces in the answer bubbles and get serious about it, because suddenly there's an immediate incentive.
"Yesterday Mr. Hall wrote that the printer's proof-reader was improving my punctuation for me, & I telegraphed orders to have him shot without giving him time to pray." -Mark Twain

"There is a level of cowardice lower than that of the conformist: the fashionable non-conformist."
Ayn Rand

". . .and the trees are all kept equal by hatchet, axe, and saw."
deek
Staff Writer
Staff Writer
Posts: 1060
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 4:31 pm
Location: Fort Wayne, IN
Contact:

Post by deek »

=^-..-^= wrote:The warm fuzzy feeling inside for doing a good job just doesn't cut it any more with kids in this consumer-goods laden Nintendo society. Show them the money. Put a pizza coupon in the kid's hand for passing ISTEP, and I bet many would stop drawing little smiley faces in the answer bubbles and get serious about it, because suddenly there's an immediate incentive.
I think that's a load of BS. Take a look at young kids...even in this consumer-goods laden Nintendo society, you give some positive reinforcement and their faces light up and they want to make you proud again. That hasn't really changed, has it?

Why is it you think everyone is motivated by a little green? Now there may be something happening between getting a warm fuzzy feeling at age 5 and what motivates a kid at age 13, but I don't think monetary incentives are going to solve the problem.
[url=http://www.deeksworld.com]deek's World[/url]
=^-..-^=
FEED ME!
FEED ME!
Posts: 971
Joined: Sat Feb 22, 2003 11:22 am
Location: Rockin' the CatBox

Post by =^-..-^= »

deek wrote: Take a look at young kids...even in this consumer-goods laden Nintendo society, you give some positive reinforcement and their faces light up and they want to make you proud again. That hasn't really changed, has it?
Uhh, the article said the program was for middle and high skoolers. For that age group, I stand by what I said about incentives.

Every side of the reason behind low ISTEP scores has been dissected; except no one has actually ever asked the kids. For them, there is no INCENTIVE to pass it, except some distant mystic thing in the future called graduation, which might have accomplished little for their parents, and many kids are not focused beyond surviving this weekend. Put an Andrew Jackson in their hand if they pass ISTEP; watch the scores miraculously rise. It sounds so crass; yet most of us ADULTS would stop producing results if the boss started paying us only in intrinsic rewards. What great training for the real world.
"Yesterday Mr. Hall wrote that the printer's proof-reader was improving my punctuation for me, & I telegraphed orders to have him shot without giving him time to pray." -Mark Twain

"There is a level of cowardice lower than that of the conformist: the fashionable non-conformist."
Ayn Rand

". . .and the trees are all kept equal by hatchet, axe, and saw."
Garr
Too Much Free Time
Too Much Free Time
Posts: 4805
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 2:22 pm
Location: Fort Wayne
Contact:

Post by Garr »

I have to admit that the idea does relate well to the world that students will face after they graduate. I'd have to know more about the implementation. I always did well on my ISTEP tests. Usually in the 98 percentile. No one motivated me but me. I just liked learning and doing a good job. That has me torn.

I think what we're looking at here is related to the problem, but not the solution. The problem that should be looked at is the nature of motivation. I (and many of my classmates) would have done just as well with or without a fiscal reward waiting at the end.
There are 10 types of people in the world.

Those who understand binary. . .

. . .and those who don't.

[url]http://www.garrmusic.com[/url]

Check out these sites:

[url=http://www.OhSoHumorous.com]OhSoHumorous.com[/url]
[url=http://www.TopDailyMemes.com]TopDailyMemes.com[/url]
[url=http://www.RandomDailyMemes.com]RandomDailyMemes.com[/url]
[url=http://www.BestDailyMemes.com]BestDailyMemes.com[/url]
[url=http://www.FortWayneMusic.om]FortWayneMusic.om[/url]
[url=http://www.Kwalis.com]Kwalis.com[/url]
[url=http://www.SoHumorous.com]SoHumorous.com[/url]
[url=http://www.FailUniversity.com]FailUniversity.com[/url]
[url=http://www.FaceFullOf.com]FaceFullOf.com[/url]
[url=http://www.NuZuDu.com]NuZuDu.com[/url]
[url=http://www.FireFlyGoods.com]FireFlyGoods.com[/url]
[url=http://www.ThePeopleBlog.com]ThePeopleBlog.com[/url]
[url=http://www.StealMyMemes.com]StealMyMemes.com[/url]
[url=http://www.DontStealMyMemes.com]DontStealMyMemes.com[/url]

More to come...
deek
Staff Writer
Staff Writer
Posts: 1060
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 4:31 pm
Location: Fort Wayne, IN
Contact:

Post by deek »

Okay, my misunderstanding on the age of students the program is targeting. But I still say that monetary incentive is not going to fit the bill in all the cases, and I also think that doing so would propagate and even stronger feeling in kids of only doing "something" if they are going to get paid...which I don't think is the best motivating strategy for kids.

I also don't think relating it to adults is an equal comparison. Middle and high schoolers are not needing to pay for shelter, food, gas, clothes, etc...most working adults are, so a paycheck is quite a bit more important. A monetary reward is giving kids extra spending money...so what, if they pass an ISTEP test they get money to spend on more drugs? As a parent, I'd rather be in charge of giving monetary rewards for scholastic performance if I thought it was a good idea, not the school.

Growing up, I used to get $1 for every A on my report card. I was excited about that, not because of the money, but because I got praise and attention from my mom and dad. In high school, I wanted to do well in school, had straight A's, graduated 6th in my class, but really could care less about standardized testing. I asked what the minimum was to get into college, figured that there was no way I could do worse than that, so didn't study, take any pre-tests, just showed up, did it as quickly as I could and left. I always scored low among my peers, but really didn't care.

I am a slacker...always have been. No amount of money that a high schooler would be getting paid would have made me care. I'd think that there are a lot of other types of students, that wouldn't care about the money either.

So, this solution might motivate 20% more students than it does today...and now we get 20% more people in the world that are motivated solely by money...yea!
[url=http://www.deeksworld.com]deek's World[/url]
bassjones
Staff Member
Staff Member
Posts: 4270
Joined: Mon May 24, 2004 1:36 pm
Contact:

Post by bassjones »

I'm a little surprised by Keith's response... Is that tongue firmly planted in your cheek? Who's going to pony up for the monetary rewards? The taxpayers. I'm not approving that. Here's my best guess as to what would happen. The kids currently getting 3.5 GPAs and above will still get 3.5 GPAs and above, the kids currently failing 7/8 of their classes will still be doing that poorly and the kids in the middle may move up a little, but not all that much. Why? Because they all still have the same parents at home. Those parents provide the motivation to study in the lower grades and in the upper grades. By the time they get to high school they're where they are going to be... behind, on target, or way ahead. Can't pass the ISTEP without the educational background heading into high school. If mom and/or dad don't give a rat's ass about their education when they're in 3rd grade, by the time they get to 10th grade they aren't getting it done no matter what carrot you dangle in front of them. Unless we lower standards even further of course. Or just give them the money for showing up. How long before some idiot at the NEA suggests that?
"brad!
...your tunes and your playing sound really great... all the best to you and god bless-
adam nitti" www.myspace.com/adamnittimusic

www.bradjonesbass.com
http://groups.myspace.com/northeastindianabassplayers
www.myspace.com/bassjones
www.myspace.com/whitehotnoise
www.esession.com/bradjones - hire me for your session from anywhere in the world.
MrSpall
Addict
Addict
Posts: 805
Joined: Fri Jan 06, 2006 4:02 pm
Location: Approximately 2 feet from the monitor
Contact:

Post by MrSpall »

This is a bad idea for a myriad of reasons, most of them already expressed above.

But what about the students that are already doing well? Take a D student, turn him into a B- student, and he gets paid handsomely. Find an A student that already spends all his free time studying, working hard to make himself (and by association the school) look good, and he gets nothing because he didn't need to attend the paid after-school tutoring.

How is that a good comparison to real life (as some supporters of the plan have said)? The best, brightest, and most capable people in this 'work pool' are being completely passed over in this 'job market' in favor of the kids who refuse to do anything on their own. My observations have always been that the best employees in any organization are motivated by something much bigger than a paycheck.

Finally, $8 an hour? Really? Just for attending the tutoring program? That's more than some adults will make, even after the minimum wage goes up. If we're going to reward students with monetary incentives, shouldn't they be something a little more reasonable? If a kid attends the tutoring for 2 hours/night for a solid week, he'll make $80. When I was in eighth grade $5 lasted me a week, now we've got to pay lazy kids $80/week to study? No thank you.

P.S. my 6 month old daughter and I started playing with her LeapFrog books last night, she's learning skills she will need to read later. That's right, she's learning. Where do I turn in her timesheet?
www.myspace.com/the1947californiacupcakecompany

www.indianajoshandtheblogofdoom.blogspot.com

We all live in a purple kangaroo, a purple kangaroo, a purple kangaroo
bassjones
Staff Member
Staff Member
Posts: 4270
Joined: Mon May 24, 2004 1:36 pm
Contact:

Post by bassjones »

MrSpall wrote:This is a bad idea for a myriad of reasons, most of them already expressed above.

But what about the students that are already doing well? Take a D student, turn him into a B- student, and he gets paid handsomely. Find an A student that already spends all his free time studying, working hard to make himself (and by association the school) look good, and he gets nothing because he didn't need to attend the paid after-school tutoring.

How is that a good comparison to real life (as some supporters of the plan have said)? The best, brightest, and most capable people in this 'work pool' are being completely passed over in this 'job market' in favor of the kids who refuse to do anything on their own. My observations have always been that the best employees in any organization are motivated by something much bigger than a paycheck.

Finally, $8 an hour? Really? Just for attending the tutoring program? That's more than some adults will make, even after the minimum wage goes up. If we're going to reward students with monetary incentives, shouldn't they be something a little more reasonable? If a kid attends the tutoring for 2 hours/night for a solid week, he'll make $80. When I was in eighth grade $5 lasted me a week, now we've got to pay lazy kids $80/week to study? No thank you.

P.S. my 6 month old daughter and I started playing with her LeapFrog books last night, she's learning skills she will need to read later. That's right, she's learning. Where do I turn in her timesheet?
She doesn't get a timesheet. You're doing your job as a parent, unlike allot of the worthless sperm and egg donors on the planet - the ones responsible for producing most of the failing students.
"brad!
...your tunes and your playing sound really great... all the best to you and god bless-
adam nitti" www.myspace.com/adamnittimusic

www.bradjonesbass.com
http://groups.myspace.com/northeastindianabassplayers
www.myspace.com/bassjones
www.myspace.com/whitehotnoise
www.esession.com/bradjones - hire me for your session from anywhere in the world.
Post Reply